EMDR and Brainspotting are both trauma therapies that use how you attend to a memory, not long retelling of it. They differ in structure and in research. EMDR follows eight set phases and has a large body of trial evidence behind it. Brainspotting uses a fixed gaze point and a looser format, and its research is still early. If you want the approach with the deeper evidence base, EMDR is the clearer starting point, and Kin Wellness offers EMDR for adults in California as part of its virtual intensive outpatient program.
This guide is for adults in California deciding between the two, and for the family members, clinicians and referring providers helping them.
TL;DR
- EMDR is a structured, eight phase therapy. Brainspotting is a less structured approach built around one eye position.
- The U.S. National Center for PTSD lists 38 randomized controlled trials of EMDR for PTSD. Brainspotting research so far is small and preliminary.
- Both need a careful screening for safety and stability first, including epilepsy, self harm risk and substance use.
- EMDR can sit inside a larger program with group work, individual therapy and medication management, which suits people who need more than weekly sessions.
- Kin Wellness is out of network and works with most PPO and HMO plans. We check benefits before anyone starts.
Table of Contents
- What EMDR is and how it works
- What Brainspotting is and how it works
- EMDR vs Brainspotting side by side
- What the research says
- Which fits which person
- Safety and readiness before either therapy
- How long each therapy takes
- When weekly therapy is not enough
- What EMDR looks like at Kin Wellness
- Start EMDR inside a virtual program
- Cost and insurance in California
- FAQ
- Check your coverage
- Sources
What EMDR is and how it works
EMDR stands for eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. A trained therapist helps you hold a distressing memory in mind while you follow a back and forth stimulus, most often eye movements, though taps or tones can be used. The goal is for the memory to feel less distressing as it is processed.
The American Psychological Association describes EMDR as moving through eight phases: history taking, preparation, assessment of the target memory, processing, and evaluation, among others. Processing a single memory generally takes one to three sessions. The APA also notes that EMDR does not require extended exposure, detailed descriptions of the trauma, challenging your beliefs or homework in the way some other trauma therapies do.
For a fuller walk through, see our guides to how EMDR works and the eight phases of EMDR.
What Brainspotting is and how it works
Brainspotting is a newer approach. The therapist helps you find a "brainspot," a gaze position linked to your distress, while you pay attention to what you feel inside. A 2022 peer reviewed comparison describes it this way and contrasts it with EMDR's memory focused, structured processing and intermittent bilateral stimulation.

The same study describes Brainspotting sessions as less stepwise, with little verbal reporting, continuous bilateral audio and more attention to body sensations. Those are features of the protocol described in the study, not proof of how it works.
EMDR vs Brainspotting side by side
| EMDR | Brainspotting | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Eight defined phases | Intentionally flexible, few set steps |
| Focus | A specific target memory | A gaze point tied to activation in the body |
| Stimulation | Intermittent bilateral movement, taps or tones | A fixed eye position, often with continuous bilateral audio |
| Talking | Some reporting between sets | Often little talking during processing |
| Research | Dozens of randomized trials for PTSD | A few small, early studies |
| Guideline standing | Named in major PTSD guidelines | Not named in the major PTSD guidelines reviewed here |
The practical difference is how it feels. EMDR gives you and your therapist a map: where you are, what memory is next, how distress is changing. Brainspotting leaves more room to follow the body without a map. Some people like that openness. Others, especially people who are juggling a job, a family and a long list of symptoms, do better with a clear plan and a way to see progress.
What the research says
EMDR
The VA's National Center for PTSD says EMDR is a structured PTSD psychotherapy and reports 38 randomized controlled trials in its PTSD Repository. A 2025 American Journal of Psychiatry review lists EMDR as a first line treatment in VA and Department of Defense guidance and a second line treatment in the APA guideline it reviews.
If PTSD is the reason you are comparing therapies, our article on EMDR for PTSD and what the trials cover goes deeper. For anxiety, see what 17 trials show for EMDR and anxiety.
Brainspotting
The Brainspotting studies are smaller and earlier:
- A 2017 study followed 76 adults in nonrandomized groups, 23 with EMDR and 53 with Brainspotting, over three 60 minute sessions. Both groups improved on self reported measures. Participants could choose their treatment, and the authors called their conclusions preliminary and asked for larger studies.
- A 2022 comparison tested EMDR, Brainspotting and body scan meditation in 40 nonclinical participants working with distressing memories. It was not a clinical PTSD trial.
- A 2023 article in the Canadian Journal of Psychiatry reports a nine patient pilot and a survey of 112 therapists. It says the preliminary evidence needs verification in randomized clinical trials.
In plain terms: Brainspotting is an approach to watch, and some people report feeling better with it. But when you are choosing the therapy you will spend weeks of time and money on, the amount of controlled research is a fair thing to weigh. EMDR has far more of it.
Which fits which person
Neither therapy is right for everyone, and the fit with your therapist matters. These questions can help you sort out where you stand.
You may lean toward EMDR if you:
- want a defined plan with phases and a way to track distress from session to session
- want a therapy named in national PTSD guidance
- are working on specific memories, such as an accident, an assault, a loss or events from work
- want therapy that can sit alongside group sessions, medication management and weekly individual therapy
You may be curious about Brainspotting if you:
- prefer a body focused, less verbal style
- do not want to work through a step by step protocol
If the second list sounds like you, it is reasonable to talk through it with a licensed trauma therapist. For the many adults who want a structured, well studied route, EMDR is where we would start.
Safety and readiness before either therapy
Both therapies stir up difficult material, so a good clinician screens first. A 2022 clinical review in BJPsych Advances says clinicians should assess safety and stability, including self harm or suicide risk, severe substance misuse, social support and psychosis symptoms. When stability is not yet adequate, trauma reprocessing may be postponed while you build skills and support first. That is a normal part of good care, not a setback.
If you have epilepsy, pseudoseizures, an eye condition or a neurological impairment, tell the clinician before EMDR starts. The same review advises careful evaluation in those cases. Talk with your neurologist or prescriber too, since eligibility is a clinical decision and not one to make on your own.
If you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or call 911. Kin Wellness is not an emergency service.
If your main concern is an eating disorder, a primary substance use disorder or detox, you need a specialized program for that. Kin Wellness is a mental health program and does not treat those conditions as a primary focus, though we do treat dual diagnosis when mental health is the main focus.
How long each therapy takes
The National Center for PTSD describes EMDR as typically delivered in weekly individual sessions of up to 90 minutes over about three months, with shorter or longer care depending on need and response. The 2025 American Journal of Psychiatry review lists 3 to 9 weekly sessions of 60 to 90 minutes. Individual memories often take one to three sessions to process, according to the APA.
Those are published patterns, not promises, and your own timeline depends on your history and goals. Our guides on EMDR session length and how an EMDR process unfolds explain what to expect, including over telehealth.
When weekly therapy is not enough
Many adults comparing these therapies are in a harder spot than one weekly hour can hold. They may be stepping down from a hospital, residential or partial hospitalization stay. They may be a nurse, physician or first responder carrying trauma from work. Or they may be a parent or partner trying to find care for someone they love.
For these readers, the choice is often less about which technique and more about what surrounds it. One hour a week of any trauma therapy leaves six days without structure. A virtual intensive outpatient program (IOP) adds that structure: several days a week of group sessions plus individual therapy, while you keep working and living at home. Our guide to weekly therapy that is not enough lists the signs, and our overview of what an IOP is explains the level of care.
Healthcare workers can read more in our piece on trauma therapy for clinicians. For a wider look at options, see trauma therapy options and the evidence. A Texas practice also explains how EMDR helps with trauma in plain language.
If you are a therapist or physician referring a patient, EMDR in an IOP gives you a defined trauma modality with a clinical team coordinating groups, individual therapy and medication, which makes the handoff easier to describe to the patient.

What EMDR looks like at Kin Wellness
The virtual IOP meets by video in small groups for three hours a session, three to five days a week. Clients choose a morning track (9 AM to 12 PM Pacific) or an evening track (5 to 8 PM Pacific), and have individual therapy every week. Most people stay 30 to 90 days. Group sessions use DBT, CBT and ACT skills. EMDR, medication management and ADHD assessment are part of the program, and a licensed clinical social worker and a physician medical director lead care. The team also includes a registered associate therapist working under clinical supervision.
We work with trauma and PTSD, depression, anxiety and panic, ADHD, OCD, personality disorders, burnout, grief and relationship issues. Our care is for adults 18 and older anywhere in California. See our page on trauma and PTSD treatment for how those conditions are approached.
If you take psychiatric medication, talk with your prescriber before starting, stopping or changing anything, whatever therapy you choose.
Our view: structure matters when life is already full
When someone arrives in our program carrying trauma, burnout or both, the first question is rarely which technique has the better name. It is whether the care is built so they can use it. We chose EMDR as part of our program because it comes with a clear structure, a large research base and a way for the client and clinician to see where they are in the work.
We also believe trauma work does not happen in a vacuum. Someone processing a memory on Tuesday still has a shift on Wednesday and a family to care for. That is why we pair EMDR with small groups, weekly individual therapy and medication management in one program, led by a licensed clinical social worker and a physician medical director.
Our groups use DBT, CBT and ACT skills, so between EMDR sessions clients are practicing ways to steady themselves. If you want a trauma therapy with defined phases inside a program that supports the rest of your week, EMDR at Kin Wellness is built for that.
Kin Wellness Clinical Team
Start EMDR inside a virtual program
If you are ready to look at EMDR, our virtual IOP gives you trauma therapy, groups and individual sessions from home, on a morning or evening schedule. You can read about EMDR at Kin Wellness or the full virtual intensive outpatient program.

If evenings are the only time you have, the evening IOP runs 5 to 8 PM Pacific.
Cost and insurance in California
Kin Wellness is out of network. We work with most PPO and HMO plans and check your benefits before you start, so you know what your plan may cover. We do not accept Medi-Cal or Medicare. We do not publish a price for the program, because what you pay depends on your plan and out of network benefits.
When you speak to any provider, ask whether the therapist is trained and credentialed in the method, whether they are in network, how many sessions they expect and what you will owe per session. Ask the same of an insurer: whether your plan covers out of network outpatient mental health care and what your deductible is.
FAQ
Is Brainspotting better than EMDR?
There is no research showing Brainspotting works better overall. EMDR has far more controlled trials behind it, including 38 randomized trials for PTSD listed by the VA. The best fit also depends on your history and your therapist.
Can you do EMDR if you have epilepsy?
Possibly, but it needs a clinician's assessment first. A 2022 clinical review advises careful evaluation when someone has epilepsy, pseudoseizures, eye conditions or neurological impairment. Talk with your neurologist and your therapist before starting.
How long does EMDR take?
The National Center for PTSD describes weekly individual sessions of up to 90 minutes for about three months, with shorter or longer care depending on need. A single memory often takes one to three sessions to process. Your own timeline will vary.
Does EMDR work over video?
Yes, EMDR can be delivered by telehealth. Kin Wellness offers EMDR by telehealth and in person for adults in California, and our guide to the EMDR process and telehealth covers what sessions involve.
Check your coverage
If you want to know what your plan may cover, you can check your insurance benefits with Kin Wellness before you commit to anything.
Sources
- Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing for PTSD, National Center for PTSD
- Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy, American Psychological Association
- Psychotherapeutic Techniques for Distressing Memories, 2022
- Brainspotting, the efficacy of a new therapy approach for PTSD, 2017
- A Paradigm Shift in Trauma Treatment, Canadian Journal of Psychiatry
- Eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing: part 1, BJPsych Advances
- An Update on Psychotherapy for the Treatment of PTSD, American Journal of Psychiatry
- How EMDR Therapy Helps Heal Trauma and PTSD
Recommended
- EMDR Therapy Explained: What It Is and How It Works
- 8 Phases of EMDR for Trauma: What to Expect and the Evidence
- EMDR for PTSD: 30+ Trials and What to Ask Your Therapist
- Resolve a Memory in 1–3 Sessions: EMDR Process, SUD/VOC & Telehealth
Clinically reviewed by Angelina DeSanto, LCSW, Clinical Director at Kin Wellness. This article is for general information only and is not medical or mental health advice. Kin Wellness serves adults in California. If you are in crisis, call or text 988, or call 911 in an emergency.
